Southeastern Outdoors Birds & Birding
Southeastern Outdoors
Home > Outdoor Activities > Hunting > Trophy Room > Michigan Deer
Hunting GearWeb Site Promotion
   

Michigan Deer Hunting

Michigan Deer Hunting

Randy's Michigan Whitetail

Michigan's firearms deer season opened Wednesday, 11/15. I saw a doe & a real nice buck late Wednesday morning but couldn't get a shot. Saw a few does Thursday.

Friday I started out at first light and quickly saw several deer in the viewing lane right behind the house, sniffing around where a few apples & some corn had been. One stepped aside, a nice doe, so since I saw no antlers anywhere I took a shot at the doe and hit her low thru the rib cage. She bounded out of sight so I walked on out there, at which time the other deer ran off and the wounded one with them. As it turned out, my shot blasted thru and ripped the end out of the sack around her heart, just at the tip. She bled real good but unfortunately made it across the ditch [property boundary] where another hunter shot her from a treestand, breaking her spine between the shoulders. That put her down for good.

When he shot, I was about 50 yards from him, right at the ditch, looking for a way across since it is very full. I called out to him and asked if he'd finished off my doe and he said the deer he'd shot wasn't wounded. I figured he must have shot one of the other deer that were running with her and said so to him, that I'd come on around and have a look. A couple minutes later he said she was hit but not badly. Well, then I had to look because the one I shot & was tracking had been bleeding heavily. Finally I found a fallen tree that would bear my weight so I crow-footed across and walked over to where this guy stood over the deer.

After a few informalities about where I work, the fact that I’d known his dad [his dad had worked there with me before retiring], and this guy also works for the same company in another plant, I asked whether the deer was his or mine? At first he said my shot was so low that it didn't even penetrate the chest cavity.....then when he looked it over carefully and saw it had, he said she seemed O.K. and would probably have gone a long way had he not shot her. Of course, that's just a guess so I said why not open her up & see. He agreed and proceeded to do so. An informal autopsy revealed what I related above. Again, I asked whether he intended to keep her and, while not being arrogant or antagonistic, he said he wanted to keep her.

I guess possession is 9/10ths of the law......even though there was no doubt she would have died soon from the wound of my slug [a Federal hollow-point Barnes slug] and under these conditions [good 3"-4" snow cover but the snowing had stopped] I would have surely recovered her before long. I have since adopted Fred Trost's position, shoot them in the shoulder and put them down immediately, even if it does ruin a little meat. Better that then what happened here! Sure wish I'd been shooting my rifle! Double lungs for sure!

As I left him I said that if he or his partners wounded a deer and it ran onto my property, go ahead and track it down.... At least I still had both my tags. After I walked away, I realized the guy hadn't tagged the deer....I don't even know if he had a tag for it! After our outfitter told us about some crazy stealing an elk from him & his nephew at rifle point last month and with several unsolved hunter gunshot fatalities in the next county on the news lately.... you just don't know whether to be assertive or not!

This episode and others like it are becoming increasingly common....and are well explained in a prophesy pointing to our time in history. You're probably familiar with it, recorded at Second Timothy chapter three....vss. 1-5. A very accurate description of the attitudes becoming prevalent nowadays.

[quote]But know this, that in the last days critical times hard to deal with will be here. 2 For men will be lovers of themselves, lovers of money, self-assuming, haughty, blasphemers, disobedient to parents, unthankful, disloyal, 3 having no natural affection, not open to any agreement, slanderers, without self-control, fierce, without love of goodness, 4 betrayers, headstrong, puffed up [with pride], lovers of pleasures rather than lovers of God, 5 having a form of godly devotion but proving false to its power; and from these turn away. [unquote]

I guess this shows what to expect AND how to deal with it..... :-]

[in response to a question] The gun I'm shooting is a Rem. 1100 12 gauge---2 3/4" with a Hastings Rifled barrel & 4x Bushnell scope. The slugs are Federal Premium Sabot Slugs with the Barnes 1 oz. HP "Expander" bullets. These are very similar to the Remington Copper Solids. I've been getting 5-shot groups about 6" in diameter, right at the top of a 9" paper plate target, at 100 yards.

This deer was moving at a walk, which probably explains why I hit her just behind the heart instead of thru it....shotgun slugs are much slower than rifle bullets..... with my rifle her movement would not have required any compensation, with the shotgun it obviously should have.

On Sunday afternoon, 11/19, my deer season took a great turn for the better..... :-) After 38 years of hunting, I got the biggest buck of my life. A beautiful big 8-pointer. .... this is the first deer I've every taken that I felt really should be preserved--- as in a wall mount. The antlers span over 19" wide, each beam is 20" long, both of the brow tines are over 8" long and the ones just above the brow tines are about 9" long. The sides are almost perfectly symmetrical and none of the points are broken or irregular. The antlers are not unusually massive but not spindly either, a little above average and very nicely proportioned. Very large deer, LOTS OF BURGER and a few steaks to compliments the elk..... :-)

Here’s how it happened…..After the fiasco on Friday I didn’t go out Saturday morning.. Jackie had spent the night in Greenville with her Mom, I didn’t feel well rested when the alarm went off and we already had plenty of venison [elk] in the freezer. So I went back to bed & dozed until I felt like getting up, then just lounged around the house all morning and into the afternoon. By then, though, I was feeling restless so I got around and dressed to go out & sit for a while. It was pretty nice out but it did start to snow pretty good so just before dark I decided to call it quits for the day and hustled back to the house. Coming over the knoll behind our house to where there is a clearing you can see from the house, I spooked one or more deer and heard them go crashing off thru the woods. "RATS! You sure blew that! I thought to myself"..

Once I got in, I took off my heavy outer clothes and taking the gun to the garage, took it apart for a quick wipe down, then an anti-rust spray. Back in the house I put everything away. As I walked thru the house into the den, I glanced out the window to the clearing I’d just crossed minutes ago and saw a large deer standing about a hundred yards out there! Rushing back to the other room, I grabbed & loaded the gun and rushed around to where I could get a shot. At the shot, the deer went out of sight to my right so I quickly went back and got my boots & outer clothes on, switched barrels on the gun and loaded it with buckshot. Then I grabbed a couple flashlights and headed out to track down this deer.

The sign at the scene of the shot showed that the deer had gone down, wallowed around in a furrow there, then scrambled up and ran back across the clearing and into the woods right on the same trail the doe had used the day before.. This deer was obviously dragging something and bleeding.

The trail went thru the same flooded area, then up a little ridge and on to the county drainage ditch at the property boundary. By the time I got there, it was pretty dark and this newer blood trail didn’t look distinct at all, almost as if the bleeding had stopped. The snow that had fallen lightly all afternoon got heavier and was quickly filling the tracks. I had things that HAD to be done before the next morning so I reluctantly left the trail, went back to the house and my other duties. I was still uncomfortable about the situation but wasn’t sure just what to do next. The following morning, Sunday, we went to our regular meetings and off on a short shopping trip afterward, getting home about 2:00 p.m. By a little after 2:30 p.m. I’d fiddled around with my gun a little, gotten dressed and headed out. I went back to the scene from the afternoon before and walked the trail again. It was a little warmer so the snow had softened and the speckles of blood has diffused into the snow more, showing up quite well. Again, I followed it to the ditch, frustrated.

Deciding to go to the end of the property & sit, I went about 75 yards and suddenly came upon another blood trail! Aha! I quickly backtracked it to the flooded area and found that, after coming thru there, the second deer had forked off, going straight north and across the ditch rather than northwest as the doe had. At this point the ditch is not so deep and I waded it. Within 60 yards the deer had bedded down and bled quite a bit, then got up and moved a few yards, bedding again. It did this 8-10 times in the space of 50-75 yards. As I carefully picked the trail apart my anticipation grew...I knew the deer would be close in this dense cover of wild raspberries, goldenrod and assorted swamp brush.

I’d gone about 100 yards from the ditch when the brush ahead & to my right began breaking. I pivoted, bringing my gun up as I searched for the source of the noise. There, struggling to run was a large buck, almost surely the one I’d seen Wednesday and the biggest of three I’d seen together early in October. As he ran with difficulty, I snapped a shot off when he passed between a couple trees. DOWN! OH, WOW! As the deer struggled to get up, I shot again...and missed! Calm down, Randy!

I walked on over, keeping the deer covered as it struggled but he could not regain his feet. It looked at me, then turned it’s head and strained to move forward. At about 10 feet, I drew my Ruger .357 Mag. revolver and finished the deer off with a shot in the left side of the neck.

Since I’d have to cross the ditch with the deer, I postponed field dressing until I got him back onto my side of the ditch and into the end of my 200 yard shooting lane. I didn’t want the inside drenched in ditch water! I also wanted some photos before the field dressing. Then I hustled up to the house and took the excess clothing I’d been carrying off, telling my wife Jackie that I’d gotten a monster 8-point buck. She went back to assist with the field dressing and loading the buck into the back of our pickup. I figured I’d drive right over to the MI-DNR deer check station but when I called, there was no answer. Once I got him hung in our shed, I went in to eat and started to reflect on the events of the past 24 hours. Later I moved the buck into our garage and looked him over closely to see how & where he’d been shot. At this point, as I fit pieces of this episode together, it became even more amazing.

When I shot this deer late on Saturday afternoon, he was quartering toward my right with his head down, sniffing around for food on the ground or possibly scenting the ground for does….. He was right where I’d shot the does the day before. I shot at his right shoulder but my shot apparently went low, creasing his right foreleg and breaking his left hind leg at the knee just below the thigh. Since I have an antlerless license also, I didn’t look for or even notice his antlers against his body. The postmortem examination showed his left foreleg had already been broken above the knee by a slug fired squarely from his left...

So this buck had 'run' away with both left legs broken! He had traveled about ¼ mile and was doing good trying to get away when I jumped him about 3:30 p.m. on Sunday afternoon. My first shot then had hit him in the middle of the back, putting him right down...then the revolver shot in the neck finished it... I knew from past experience and reliable accounts that deer can get along almost unhindered on three legs and sometimes they do quite well on two if the broken one[s] are broken low and/or on opposite sides. This buck had two left legs broken up high, very close to his body. The vitality & will to live he showed will always remain in the back of my mind----WHAT A BUCK!


 

 
 

Questions and answers about Tennessee deer hunting can be found in our Hunting Discussion Forums.

Hunting Info
Hunting & Shooting
Trophy Room
Tennessee WMA's
Venison Recipes
 
Sponsor Links
Outdoors-411
 
 
Related Links
Shooting Ranges
Hunting Guides
TWRA
 
Deer Hunting Books